Best Italian Restaurant in Mary Esther

Q: Where are you located?

We are located in Mary Esther, FL at 3176 US-98

Discover Authentic Italian Flavors – Bringing the True Taste of Italy to You!

🗓️ Now Open on Sundays!

We’re excited to announce that we’re now open on Sundays! Whether you’re planning a relaxing brunch, a family lunch, or dinner with friends, we’re here to make your weekend even better. 🕒 Sunday Hours: 11 AM – 8 PM

Order online

Featured

View menu

Order From Our Website

Order directly from our website to save money in fees, get faster service, earn free food via our rewards program, and support local business.

Order Now

Only Fresh Ingredients

There's no doubt that when it comes to taste, quality ingredients make all the difference. That's why at Da' Matteo Ristorante Pizzeria we take pride in the fact that only the best ingredients are used in our products. We want to ensure that you have an enjoyable experience with every bite. We know providing you with quality food will bring a smile to your face, so come on in and let us show you what "really good" Italian food looks like!

Made with Passion and Love

There's something special about spending time with those passionate about what they do. When you visit our restaurant, you'll be surrounded by passionate individuals dedicated to creating an exceptional dining experience for you. We believe that passion is the essential ingredient for success, whether it's in crafting delicious dishes or offering friendly service. Our team will leave you feeling fulfilled and satisfied. Don't hesitate, come and experience the joy of our secret ingredient—passion!

Come and Try Us!

Best locally-owned independent Italian restaurant in Mary Esther serving our real, authentic recipes using only the freshest ingredients. Get the best Italian restaurant near you!

This small local Italian restaurant was a delightful surprise. My husband and I shared a piemontese white cheese sausage and mushroom pizza. It reminded us of the Napoli pizza we ate in Italy itself. And we finished with a delicious piece of tiramisu. We will definitely be regulars now.

Amanda M.

The gnocchi al pesto was phenomenal. You can taste the quality of the ingredients in every bite. Hats off to the chef I will definitely ordering another here to try more!

Paul M.

If you want delicious and authentic Italian food, this is the right restaurant! Try the lasagna, you won't be disappointed! Worth every penny!

Alijah G.

My wife and I ordered a salad to share as an appetizer and each our own calzone. The salad was perfect and each of our calzones was delicious! Even leftovers were deliciously reheated in the toaster oven. Enjoyed every meal!

Chris S.

Amazing! The food is absolutely delicious! We did the mussels for starters and then I had the seafood pasta and my husband had the rigatoni--all of it was so good! Most the pasta and the bread are made in-house and you can tell!

Mrs. E.

Our Story